Tag Archives: Indian Army

Seniority or Merit – The Dilemma of Higher Military Appointments

For decades, the established convention in India for appointing the Chief of Army Staff and other apex military positions was straightforward: the senior-most eligible officer was elevated. Critics often dismissed this system as mechanical or overly rigid. Yet it rested … Continue reading

Posted in Appraisal System, Blogitorial, COAS, Democracy, Higher Defence Management | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Dissent, Disobedience and Defiance

Constructive dissent is essential to good military leadership — but it must occur within the decision-making process, not after the fact. Public post-retirement criticism by senior commanders risks crossing from professional dissent into defiance or disobedience. There is a  deeply … Continue reading

Posted in Blogitorial, Civil Military Relations, COAS, Higher Defence Management, National Issues | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Rules, Fools and Exceptions

A recent post by a retired bureaucrat about rules and precedents reminded me of an interesting and educational encounter I had with regulations a couple of decades ago. The year was 1993, and the place was Chandimandir. But let me … Continue reading

Posted in Management, Military, Welfare | Tagged , , | 17 Comments

Mind Over Merit

In a recent piece in The Print, Gen Panag discusses the recent government decision to adopt a ‘merit based’ approach over ‘seniority based’ on the promotion of Lt Gens, and opines it is a move in the right direction. He also … Continue reading

Posted in Appraisal System, Blogitorial, Higher Defence Management, Military, Promotion System, Reforms | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

1965 – No Victor no Vanquished?

The 1965 India – Pakistan war was brought to an end on 22nd September 1965 by a ceasefire brokered by the United Nations. The situation on ground as on that day in various sectors was such that India had a … Continue reading

Posted in Military, Military History, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

Uniformly Crazy

Growing malaise of the misuse of articles of uniform by veterans while appearing on television and public functions needs to be curbed – by peer pressure, or else by enforcing regulations on the issue. Continue reading

Posted in Blogitorial, Military, Veterans | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Gen Thimayya’s Resignation – Statement by Pt Nehru in Parliament and debate – 02 Sep 1959

In Aug 1959, Gen Thimayya submitted his resignation to the Prime Minister. There was a furore in the papers and in parliament, with questions being raised about the reasons behind it. Nehru gave a statement in parliament about the resignation. Here is the full text of his statement and the limited debate that followed. Continue reading

Posted in Blogitorial, Civil Military Relations, Military, Politics, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Sadda Haq Aithe Rakh

My understanding of the way performance and rewards work is as follows. Performance deserves reward, commensurate to achievement and based on established norms. The organisation  enables performance through provision of resources and infrastructure, while the performer provides sweat and talent … Continue reading

Posted in Blogitorial, Politics | Tagged , , , , , , , | 53 Comments

Age Row – Some Facts

Going by the round and round arguments about Gen VK Singh’s age row, it seems people have not gone beyond the sound bytes and headlines to understand the real issue involved. The issue in question was NOT the actual year … Continue reading

Posted in COAS, Media, Military, Politics | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Sab theek hai sahib

The Indian soldier, or Jawan as he is affectionately called, is known for not cribbing under the most adverse circumstances. If you ask your driver who has been waiting well past his lunch time for you to emerge from a … Continue reading

Posted in Blogitorial, Civil Military Relations, Equipment, Military, Politics, Values | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment